High-stakes business documents
Board papers for people who will read one page
Directors may have a whole pack of papers to read before a meeting, each one asking them for something. We look at how to write a paper whose first page gives them what they need.
A board pack can hold many papers, and directors often have to work through them before the meeting alongside the rest of their work. Each paper asks the board for something, even if it’s only to note what has happened. Every paper is also competing for whatever attention a director has left after reading the ones before it. By the later papers in a pack, a reader may go through the first page carefully and only skim the rest.
In the UK, the Financial Reporting Council’s guidance on the corporate governance code sets out what board papers should do. As well as being “accurate, clear, comprehensive and up-to-date”, each paper should “contain a summary of the contents”, should tell the director what’s expected on the issue, and should be delivered “sufficiently in advance of the meeting” (Financial Reporting Council [FRC], 2024a, para. 78). The guidance is written for listed companies, but the advice is useful for any board. Taken together, it means writing so that a director who reads only the first page still knows what they’re being asked to do, and why.
Say what you’re asking for, at the top
Make the request the first thing a director reads: whether the board is being asked to decide, approve, discuss, or simply note. A paper that starts with the background and reaches the request on page four leaves the board reading the whole document to find out what it’s being asked for. Put the purpose of the paper, what you’re asking for, and management’s recommendation in the opening paragraph, and give each one a label so that it’s easy to find again during the meeting.
Recommendation first, rationale second
Our guide to writing an executive summary that gets read explains why busy readers need the conclusion first and the reasoning after it, and a board paper’s first page works the same way. The FRC guidance asks for a summary in every paper (FRC, 2024a, para. 78), and the opening page is the natural place for it. A director who reads only that page should know what management recommends and the main reasons for it. The pages that follow should support the summary without changing it. If something on page six alters the picture given on page one, move it to page one.
Show how the proposal was developed
For significant decisions, the FRC guidance suggests describing in the paper how the proposal was developed and challenged before it reached the board. That lets directors who weren’t involved assess how the proposal came about before they weigh its merits (FRC, 2024a, para. 31). In practice, this can be a short paragraph near the start that sets out the options considered, who reviewed them, and what changed as a result.
Give the board what it needs to decide, and no more
Board papers tend to grow because authors add material in case someone asks about it. The FRC lists “poor quality papers” and “inadequate information or analysis” among the risk factors for poor decisions by boards (FRC, 2024a, para. 29, fig. 3). A paper padded with detail the board doesn’t need can fall into both categories: the facts the decision depends on may all be there, but directors can easily miss them. For each section, ask whether the board needs it to make this particular decision. If it doesn’t, move it to an appendix or cut it. A decision paper should cover the options that were considered, the recommended option and the reasons for choosing it, the risks, the cost, and what happens if the board says no.
Be open about risk and uncertainty
Under the UK code, the board is responsible for deciding “the nature and extent of the principal risks the company is willing to take in order to achieve its long-term strategic objectives” (FRC, 2024b, Principle O). A paper that presents its recommendation as risk-free leaves out important information the board needs before it can make that judgment. Say what could go wrong, how likely it is, and what would be done about it. Mark any figure that’s an estimate, and say how confident you are in it.
Write for directors outside your specialism
Many boards include members who don’t share the author’s expertise, so the paper has to work for the least specialist reader at the table. Spell out every acronym, and replace any jargon that an informed reader from outside your field wouldn’t understand. If the paper follows on from earlier papers, summarize what they said, since not every director will remember them or have them to hand. Where technical detail is needed, put it in an appendix and give a plain-language summary in the body of the paper.
Check the pack as a whole
Directors may read several papers on the same subject in one sitting, so inconsistencies between papers are easy to spot: a figure that differs from the one in the finance paper, for example, or a risk rated high in one paper and medium in another. Before the pack goes out, someone should read it from start to finish, looking only for contradictions like these. If your organization produces a pack every month, this cross-reading can be hard to fit into the days before the meeting, along with keeping a house style across many authors. A group account lets you reserve our time for that work in advance.
How long a board paper should be
A long paper can signal, before a director has read a word, that the author wasn’t sure what mattered. As a starting point, we’d suggest about three pages plus appendices for a decision paper, and a single page is often enough for a paper the board only needs to note. The layout makes a difference as well: short paragraphs and headings that state what each section concludes make a paper quicker to read, as does a table wherever you’re comparing options.
A test before the paper goes out
Before a paper goes into the pack, give the first page to a colleague who wasn’t involved in writing it, and ask them what the board is being asked to decide and what management recommends. When they can answer both in a sentence, the first page is doing its job. Otherwise, the board is likely to spend part of the meeting asking those same questions.
Our line editing service makes sure your entire pack is in plain language and consistent. If a paper needs more than that, for example moving the recommendation up to the first page, the work becomes developmental editing, which deals with the order and shape of a document as well as its wording.
References
- Financial Reporting Council. (2024a, January 29). Corporate governance code guidance. https://www.frc.org.uk/library/standards-codes-policy/corporate-governance/corporate-governance-code-guidance/
- Financial Reporting Council. (2024b). UK corporate governance code. https://www.frc.org.uk/documents/6709/UK_Corporate_Governance_Code_2024_a2hmQmY.pdf
Board pack going out?
Send us the papers and the date, and we’ll agree the scope with you before quoting.
Get a quote