High-stakes business documents
What makes a proposal readable to a busy evaluator
Evaluators often score proposals one question at a time against published criteria. We look at what that means for the way you write yours.
The person scoring your proposal likely has several others to get through in the same week. Yours might land on their desk at the end of a long day. With their scoring sheet open next to them and a deadline of their own to meet, they’re less likely to read your document from start to finish: more often, they’re working through their list of criteria, looking for each point in turn, and allotting marks for things that are clearly visible to them. What they cannot find won’t be added to your score.
Writing for that reader is a different skill from writing a good document in general, and it starts with knowing how your document will be read. In public-sector tenders, much of that is written down: in the UK, for example, the buyer has to publish its award criteria and the assessment method it will use (Cabinet Office, 2026).
Your proposal may be read a section at a time
In a formal evaluation, your proposal often isn’t read by one person from start to finish. UK government guidance recommends that at least two evaluators score each bid independently, with a moderator helping them reach a consensus, and that the same evaluator assesses every bidder’s response to a given question (Cabinet Office, 2021). The person marking how you’ll deliver may not see what you wrote on risk at all, but they’ll read your delivery plan alongside every competitor’s.
Each section therefore has to work on its own. It should respond to what was asked and point to its evidence without relying on something said thirty pages earlier, restating any context it needs. If the buyer asks for an executive summary, it needs to stand alone too. Our guide to writing an executive summary that gets read explains how.
Lead with the buyer’s problem
Many proposals open with the supplier’s history and values. That material reads much the same in every bid, and it doesn’t tell an evaluator what they usually want to know first, which is whether you understand what the buyer needs. Open instead with the buyer’s situation, in their own terms, and include a detail that shows you listened. That sets your proposal apart from the bids that begin with the supplier. Your capability comes next, as evidence that you can solve the problem you’ve just described.
Structure it to the published criteria
Where evaluation criteria are published, evaluators score against them using the stated method (Cabinet Office, 2026). Following the criteria as listed, under the same headings, lets the evaluator find what they need without hunting for it. In EU public procurement, buyers generally have to say how much each criterion is worth, and where that isn’t possible, they rank the criteria in order of importance instead (Directive 2014/24/EU, 2014, art. 67(5)). Either way, you know what the buyer values most before you start writing. A proposal that follows its own logic, however good, leaves the evaluator to do the mapping. Our guide to how tender evaluators read a scoring rubric goes into more detail.
Replace general claims with specific ones
“We have extensive experience in this sector” gives an evaluator nothing to score: every competitor can say the same. “We delivered a similar program for a comparable authority last year, where moving the training online halved the no-show rate, so we’ve built that into this plan” is more likely to earn marks because it can be verified and shows how you think. Wherever your draft makes a general claim, replace it with a specific one that the evaluator can check and point to when they record their score.
Make every answer quick to find and read
A wall of text where a table would do, or an answer that opens with background before getting to the point, slows the evaluator down, and a tired reader can be less generous. Open each section with a direct response to the question, then set out the evidence that supports it.
Keep the pricing consistent with the promises
Price and quality are often assessed separately, and UK guidance recommends evaluating finance models independently of the technical specification (Cabinet Office, 2021). A mismatch between the two can still cause trouble, though. If the delivery section promises something the price doesn’t cover, you may still be held to it, and if the price implies a lower level of service than the proposal describes, the buyer may question it later. Before submission, someone should read the two side by side and reconcile them. This is also one way for a model-assisted bid to go wrong, since a model can easily add commitments that haven’t been costed properly.
Make many authors sound like one organization
A proposal in which the terminology changes between sections, the numbering breaks, the figures are formatted three ways, and the tone shifts from one author to the next looks rushed, and that can leave an evaluator wondering how carefully you’d deliver the work itself. Giving a multi-author bid one consistent voice is much of what we do when we edit a business document, so build time for it into the bid schedule, ahead of the final rush to submit.
A last pass as the evaluator
If there’s time for only one pass before submission, make it a read-through as the evaluator, with the criteria open beside you and a time limit for each section, so that you’re reading with the same pressure they’ll be under. Check that each answer responds to the question that was asked and doesn’t depend on a part of the document its evaluator might not see.
References
- Cabinet Office. (2021). Bid evaluation guidance note. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/60a387e48fa8f56a3e32fa9a/Bid_evaluation_guidance_note_May_2021.pdf
- Cabinet Office. (2026, August 17). Guidance: Assessing competitive tenders. GOV.UK. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/procurement-act-2023-guidance-documents-procure-phase/assessing-competitive-tenders-html
- Directive 2014/24/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 26 February 2014 on public procurement and repealing Directive 2004/18/EC. (2014). Official Journal of the European Union, L 94, 65–242. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2014/24/oj
Proposal in draft?
Send us the draft and the deadline, and we’ll agree the scope with you before quoting.
Get a quote